Evictions are never easy, but they are sometimes necessary. Property managers must follow the legal eviction process for property managers carefully to avoid costly delays, lawsuits, or wrongful eviction claims. A single mistake—such as issuing an incorrect eviction notice procedure or mishandling tenant belongings—can lead to financial penalties or restarting the process.
This guide outlines the essential steps to ensure a smooth, legal eviction process for property managers while minimizing financial loss.
Understanding the True Cost of Evictions
Evictions are expensive. The average total cost is about $3,500, including legal fees, lost rent, and court costs. In some cases, the costs exceed this due to property damage, locksmith fees, and vacancy losses.
The process takes 3–4 weeks on average, though tenant disputes can extend it. Landlords must also account for stress, time lost in court, and the risk of property damage before possession is regained.
Step 1: Review the Lease and Grounds for Eviction
The legal eviction process for property managers should always be based on a clear lease violation. The most common causes include:
- Non-payment of rent – The most frequent issue. Ensure rent is past the grace period before taking action.
- Lease violations – Unauthorized occupants, illegal activity, excessive noise, or property damage.
- Holdover tenants – Lease expiration without renewal, yet the tenant refuses to vacate.
Landlords cannot evict tenants for discriminatory or retaliatory reasons. Reviewing lease agreements and tenant eviction laws before proceeding is crucial.
Step 2: Serve the Proper Eviction Notice
A legal eviction process for property managers begins with a written eviction notice procedure. Common types include:
- Pay or Quit Notice – Typically 3–5 days for tenants to pay overdue rent or vacate.
- Cure or Quit Notice – Allows a tenant to fix a lease violation (e.g., unauthorized pet).
- Unconditional Quit Notice – Immediate eviction for severe violations (e.g., illegal activity).
Proper eviction notice procedures are crucial. Some states require certified mail, personal service, or posting the notice at the property. Failure to follow tenant eviction laws correctly can lead to case dismissal, wasting time and money.
Step 3: File an Eviction Lawsuit (Unlawful Detainer)
If the notice period expires with no resolution, the next step in the legal eviction process for property managers is filing an unlawful detainer action in court. This includes:
- Submitting a complaint and summons outlining the lease violation.
- Paying court filing fees (varies by state).
- Serving the lawsuit to the tenant via a process server or sheriff.
Once filed, the court schedules a hearing. Tenants may contest the eviction, citing landlord negligence or improper notice. Property managers should prepare lease agreements, payment records, and maintenance history as evidence.
Step 4: Court Hearing and Judgment
At the court hearing, the judge determines whether the legal eviction process for property managers can proceed. Possible outcomes include:
- Judgment for possession – The landlord wins, and the tenant must vacate.
- Tenant’s defense succeeds – The case is dismissed (e.g., improper eviction notice procedures).
- Mediation or settlement – Courts may encourage landlords and tenants to agree on move-out terms.
If the landlord wins, a Judgment for Possession is issued, legally ending the tenancy. However, if the tenant refuses to leave, further action is required.
Step 5: Enforce Possession with Law Enforcement
Once the court orders eviction, the landlord must coordinate with law enforcement. This final step in the legal eviction process for property managers includes:
- Requesting a sheriff’s eviction – This may require an additional fee and waiting period.
- Scheduling a lockout – The sheriff supervises the removal.
- Changing the locks immediately after the tenant is removed.
Self-help evictions (changing locks, cutting utilities) are illegal and can lead to lawsuits. Property managers must follow legal tenant eviction laws to avoid penalties.
Avoiding Legal Pitfalls in Evictions
The legal eviction process for property managers is complex, and mistakes can be costly. Common eviction compliance checklist errors include:
- Improper eviction notice procedures – Courts dismiss cases with incorrect notice service.
- Accepting partial rent – Some states reset eviction timelines if partial rent is accepted.
- Self-help evictions – Cutting off utilities or changing locks before a legal order can result in fines.
- Violating storage laws – If a tenant leaves belongings, landlords must store them for a set period.
Following tenant eviction laws carefully prevents costly legal disputes.
Reducing the Need for Evictions
Preventing evictions is always preferable. Strategies include:
1. Strong Tenant Screening
Evicted tenants are 3x more likely to face eviction again. Conduct credit checks, rental history reviews, and income verification before approval.
2. Proactive Rent Collection & Payment Plans
42% of tenants who miss one rent payment incur another late fee the next month. Offering weekly or biweekly rent installment plans can help keep tenants current.
3. “Cash for Keys” Agreements
Providing an incentive (waiving back rent in exchange for leaving voluntarily) can be cheaper than eviction.
Final Thoughts
The legal eviction process for property managers must be handled carefully to stay compliant and avoid financial losses. By following proper eviction notice procedures, maintaining accurate documentation, and ensuring tenant eviction laws compliance, landlords can navigate evictions successfully. Make the smart choice for your properties today. Choose Beagle and elevate the resident experience to new heights.
Related Blog Posts:
Beagle is the #1 platform for property managers to launch profit-maximizing reinsurance and resident benefit programs that tenants love through our association.
Book a Demo Today
