Pet ownership among renters is at an all-time high, reshaping what pet-friendly property management means today. One national survey found that nearly 90% of renters have a pet (American Apartment Owners), and more than half of those without pets plan to get one within the next year (American Apartment Owners). With such a large portion of tenants living with furry companions, rental communities can no longer treat pet policies as an afterthought. A welcoming pet policy isn’t just a perk—it’s often a deciding factor for tenants. In fact, over 80% of renters say a pet-friendly policy plays a major role in where they choose to live (American Apartment Owners).

Embracing pets in rentals comes with responsibility. Without proper guidelines, unvetted pets can lead to property damage or conflicts, undermining the very comfort that draws pet lovers in. This is where effective pet screening steps in as a game-changer. By systematically evaluating each pet and pet owner, property managers can enhance safety and safeguard their bottom line. Thorough pet screening creates a safer environment by weeding out high-risk situations—like aggressive animal behavior or missing vaccinations—before they become incidents. Simultaneously, it opens the door to increased revenue; welcoming pets broadens your tenant pool and can justify pet fees or insurance programs that boost income.

In this blog post, we will explore why structured pet policies and screening are essential in multifamily properties, how automated pet compliance tools and insurance-backed programs work, and best practices for implementing a pet screening program that keeps everyone happy (and your property protected).

Why Pet Screening is Essential for Property Managers

Allowing pets in rental properties brings great opportunities but also some risks if not managed properly. Not screening pets—essentially allowing any animal without evaluation—can lead to several issues:

Property Damage: Untrained or anxious pets might chew fixtures, scratch floors, or soil carpets. Even minor damage across units adds up in repair costs and turnover time.

Liability Issues: In a worst-case scenario, an aggressive dog could bite a neighbor or a visitor. The property owner might be held liable for injuries if proper precautions weren’t in place, leading to costly insurance claims or lawsuits.

Neighbor Disputes: Noise complaints from barking or howling, or issues with pet waste in common areas, can sour relationships between neighbors. A single irresponsible pet owner can negatively affect the comfort of many residents.

Unauthorized Pets: Without a system to track pets, tenants might sneak in animals that violate lease terms—such as extra pets or disallowed large breeds. Unauthorized pets mean unvetted animals on the property, increasing risk and defeating the purpose of having pet rules.

Implementing structured pet policies and automated pet screening tools is the proactive way to avoid these pitfalls. With a formal pet screening process in place, every animal is known, approved, and meets the community’s standards. This provides property managers with peace of mind knowing exactly who and what is living in their units. While data shows that most pet-owning renters are responsible—only about 9% of pets cause damage, and when they do it averages just $191 in repairs (PetScreening)—screening helps identify exceptions before they become problematic.

A structured pet policy creates a fair, consistent process. All applicants go through the same review, helping protect against claims of discrimination (especially when handling assistance animals versus pets). It sets clear expectations: tenants know upfront what documentation and behavior standards are required, which attracts responsible pet owners while deterring those who might hide issues. Moreover, a well-implemented pet screening program becomes a strong selling point. Pet owners appreciate a community that welcomes their animals, and even tenants without pets value that rules are in place to keep the property clean and quiet. Pet-friendly communities often see higher occupancy and longer resident stays, directly benefiting the bottom line (PetScreening).

How Automated Pet Screening Works

Modern technology has made pet screening easier than ever. Gone are the days when managers personally interviewed every pet or sorted through endless vet papers. Automated pet screening platforms now handle the heavy lifting by using algorithms and databases to assess each pet’s risk profile.

Pet Profile Creation

The process begins with the pet owner—whether an applicant or current tenant—filling out an online profile for their pet. This includes key details such as the pet’s breed, age, weight, vaccination records, spay/neuter status, any history of bites or property damage, and a recent photo. It’s essentially like a rental application for the pet, covering health, behavior, and ownership history.

Assigning Pet Ratings

Once the profile is submitted, the platform evaluates the information and assigns a risk rating or score to the pet. For instance, PetScreening.com uses a proprietary algorithm to review vet records, past behavior, microchip data, and more, yielding a “FIDO Score” on a 1-to-5 paw scale (Hypepotamus). A higher score indicates a low-risk pet with a clean bill of health and a responsible owner; a lower score might indicate potential concerns, such as missing vaccinations or previous incidents.

Verification of Vaccinations and Compliance

A robust pet compliance tool does more than rely on the owner’s word. It verifies the uploaded documentation—such as vaccination certificates, proof of spay/neuter, and pet license registrations—and may even cross-check microchip IDs or call veterinary references. The aim is to ensure every pet is up-to-date on shots and compliant with lease rules. For tenants claiming their dog is an emotional support or service animal, the system handles additional paperwork to verify authenticity (Hypepotamus).

Automated Flags and Recommendations

After processing the profile, the platform provides the property manager with the pet’s rating and any pertinent notes. High-risk pets can be flagged for additional review or even declined, while low-risk pets are approved with confidence. Many systems integrate with property management software, ensuring that pet screening results automatically sync with lease records, providing a seamless, data-driven solution.

Ongoing Monitoring

Pet screening isn’t a one-time event. Automated systems allow for continuous monitoring of pet profiles over the lease term. If a tenant adds a new pet or if circumstances change—such as a previously well-behaved pet showing signs of aggression—the system updates the profile accordingly. This ongoing monitoring ensures that every pet remains compliant throughout the tenancy.

Pet Damage and Liability Protection Through Insurance Programs

Even with diligent screening, accidents can happen. This is where insurance-backed pet protection comes into play. Traditionally, landlords have relied on pet deposits and monthly pet rent to buffer against potential damage. However, a growing trend toward pet liability waivers and specialized insurance programs offers a modern solution with less hassle.

Pet liability waivers replace the need for pet deposits or additional pet rent. Instead of collecting a $300 pet deposit or charging $30 per month, property managers require enrollment in a pet damage liability program. With services like Beagle, tenants pay a modest fee for a pet damage protection plan. In return, the property receives an insurance-backed guarantee covering pet-caused damages up to $1,500 for property damage and up to $20,000 for bodily injury liability (Beagle).

These programs handle the claims process directly. If a tenant’s pet causes damage, the landlord files a claim with the provider, which reimburses the owner quickly—often much faster than traditional deposit dispute resolutions. This system not only protects the property but also minimizes administrative overhead since managers no longer need to track or refund deposits.

From a revenue standpoint, switching to a pet liability waiver program can lower upfront move-in costs for tenants, making properties more attractive. Studies indicate that nearly 60% of renters would be less likely to rent an apartment that requires a pet deposit (American Apartment Owners). Lower move-in costs lead to faster occupancy and higher tenant satisfaction, which in turn drive better retention and potentially higher rents. Additionally, some programs share a portion of the fee with property managers, creating an ancillary income stream.

Data-Driven Insights on Pet-Friendly Rentals

Data supports the notion that effective pet screening and liability programs are both safer and more profitable. For example:

• Pet ownership among renters hovers around two-thirds of households, and pet-friendly policies are a deciding factor for over 80% of renters (American Apartment Owners).
• Studies show that only about 9% of pets cause damage, and when they do, the average repair cost is approximately $191 (PetScreening).
• In a case study, properties implementing deposit alternatives and pet screening saw vacancy rates drop as more units were filled by pet owners (American Apartment Owners).

These numbers make it clear: being pet-friendly with robust screening is not only a sound risk management strategy but also a competitive advantage that drives higher occupancy and revenue.

Best Practices for Implementing a Pet Screening Program

To successfully integrate pet screening into your property management, consider the following best practices:

1. Establish a Clear Pet Policy:
Develop and document a comprehensive pet policy that outlines all requirements—such as vaccination records, breed restrictions, and behavior standards. A clear policy sets expectations for every applicant and helps avoid disputes later.

2. Use Automated Pet Screening Tools:
Invest in an automated pet screening platform that integrates with your property management software. These platforms can validate documents, assign risk ratings, and continuously monitor pet compliance, ensuring every unit is up-to-date with minimal manual intervention.

3. Educate Your Leasing Team:
Train your leasing agents to explain the pet screening process and its benefits to prospective tenants. Clear communication builds trust and helps residents understand that the process is designed to protect everyone’s well-being.

4. Communicate Clearly with Tenants:
When new tenants move in, provide a detailed explanation of the pet screening process and any associated fees or benefits. This transparency ensures tenants understand what is expected and the advantages of having a safe, well-managed pet policy.

5. Monitor and Update Policies Regularly:
Regularly review the performance of your pet screening program. Use data and tenant feedback to refine the screening criteria and update your pet policy as needed. Consistent monitoring helps ensure that the program remains effective and that any lapses are caught early.

6. Leverage Technology for Ongoing Compliance:
Adopt platforms that offer ongoing monitoring and real-time updates. Automated notifications can alert you when a pet’s documentation expires or when a new pet is added to a unit, ensuring continuous compliance and minimizing risk.

7. Integrate Insurance-Backed Solutions:
Consider pairing your pet screening program with insurance-backed pet protection. This dual approach not only screens and evaluates pets but also provides financial coverage in case of damage, offering comprehensive protection for your property.

Real-World Success Stories

Many property managers have successfully implemented pet screening programs with significant benefits:

• A multifamily operator reported that using an automated pet screening tool reduced their maintenance calls related to pet damage by 38% (PetScreening). This reduction in service calls not only saved money but also improved tenant satisfaction, as residents experienced fewer disruptions.
• Another property management firm noted that after introducing a pet liability waiver program, their occupancy rates improved by 30% within six months (American Apartment Owners). Tenants were attracted by the lower move-in costs and the confidence that the property had robust risk management measures in place.
• In one survey, properties that employed structured pet screening and related insurance programs reported higher resident retention and longer lease terms, with occupancy rising to nearly 100% in some cases (PetScreening).

These real-world examples demonstrate that a well-implemented pet screening program not only minimizes risk but also enhances overall property performance by improving tenant satisfaction and reducing vacancies.

Conclusion

The rise of pets in rental housing is a trend that’s here to stay, and forward-thinking property managers are adapting by embracing pets with open arms—and smart safeguards. Effective pet screening is essential because it not only protects your property from potential damage and liability but also opens the door to increased revenue and higher tenant satisfaction.

By systematically evaluating each pet and its owner, you create a safe, controlled environment that attracts responsible pet owners and discourages potential issues. Automated pet screening platforms simplify the process, ensuring continuous compliance and freeing your staff from tedious manual checks. When paired with insurance-backed pet protection, these systems provide a comprehensive solution that safeguards both your property and your bottom line.

Ultimately, implementing a structured pet screening program transforms pet-friendly policies from a potential liability into a competitive advantage. Happy, well-vetted pet owners are more likely to stay long-term, reducing turnover costs and maintaining higher occupancy levels. As rental markets become increasingly competitive, the ability to offer a safe, welcoming, and well-managed community becomes a powerful selling point.

Make the smart choice for your properties today. Choose Beagle and elevate the resident experience to new heights.
‍

Related Blog Posts:

• Security Deposit Alternatives | Tenant-Friendly Deposits
• Security Deposit Replacement | Simplify Move-Ins & Protect Rentals
• How to Get Rid of Cat Dander in Your Rental Property | Complete Cleaning Guide

‍